We can’t argue against social proof as a must-have in every marketer’s toolkit. It’s a trick that always works. But lately, it’s gotten a bit overused. Everywhere you look, brands are flashing testimonials, reviews, and those “As seen on” logos.
So, how do you set yourself apart when everyone’s playing the same game? That’s where things get interesting.
In this article, we’re not going to rehash the basics. You know those already. Instead, we’re diving into the advanced tactics that will elevate your social proof from tired to magnetic. We’ll look at ways to build trust that go beyond the usual suspects and dig into the strategies that drive real conversions.
Expect actionable tips you can use right away, insights that’ll help you cut through the noise, and a fresh take on what really moves the needle when it comes to earning trust online. Let’s take your social proof to the next level.
Leverage Authority of Third-Party Review Platforms
Why settle for testimonials on your own site when you can tap into the power of established review platforms? This strategy takes social proof up a notch by borrowing credibility from trusted third-party sources.
Why This Works
People are clever. They know you control what appears on your website. However, when they see reviews on independent platforms, it carries more weight. It shows you’re confident enough in your product or service to let customers speak freely.
How to Do It Right
- Claim your business profiles on popular review sites like Google, Trustpilot, Yelp, or industry-specific platforms.
- Encourage happy customers to leave reviews there, not just on your site.
- Make it easy by sending follow-up emails with direct links to these platforms after a purchase or interaction.
- Don’t just let those reviews sit there, though. Showcase them strategically on your site.
- Pull in live feeds or screenshots that update automatically. This keeps your social proof fresh and authentic. Outdated reviews can hurt more than they help.
Real-World Examples
Now, let’s look at two brands nailing this tactic:
Classical Guitar Shed, an online guitar-learning platform, features a “Here’s what people are saying” section on its homepage. Instead of generic testimonials, it displays actual Google reviews.
Source: classicalguitarshed.com
This smart move lets potential students see honest feedback from fellow guitarists, building trust in their teaching methods.
The second example is SopranoVillas, a company specializing in exclusive Italian villas for rent.
On the homepage, the company prominently displays a Trustpilot review along with a link to its Trustpilot page. This instantly signals to visitors that many others have had positive rental experiences.
Source: sopranovillas.com
Both brands go beyond basic testimonials by leveraging well-known review platforms. They’re not just telling you they’re great but showing you what real people think, backed by the authority of trusted third-party sites.
This is a simple yet powerful way to boost credibility and stand out in a crowded market.
Connect Testimonials to Third-Party Reviews
We all know testimonials are powerful. 88% of marketing teams say they boost conversion rates.
To make them even more convincing, simply link them to third-party reviews.
Why This Works
This strategy works because it combines the best of both worlds. You get the personal touch of curated testimonials with the credibility of independent review platforms.
This approach gives potential customers the reassurance they need, as they know these testimonials aren’t just cherry-picked but are part of a larger, verified body of feedback.
How to Do It Right
- Collect standout reviews from platforms like Google, Trustpilot, Tripadvisor, G2, etc.
- Look for ones that tell a story or highlight specific benefits.
- Then, feature these on your site alongside a link or badge from the review platform. This way, visitors can easily verify the authenticity of the praise.
- Encourage your happy customers to post their testimonials on these platforms, too. It’s a win-win: you get fresh content for your site and get to boost your presence on review sites.
Real-World Example
Let’s look at how Eden Emerald Mortgages, a top Australian mortgage broker, nails this approach.
On the homepage, the broker showcases verified Google reviews, complete with star ratings and user profiles.
This clever move adds an extra layer of trust. Potential clients can see real feedback from fellow customers who’ve navigated the mortgage maze with Eden Emerald’s help.
Source: eemortgagebroker.com.au
This approach makes the testimonials more believable and reinforces their reputation as a trusted player in the mortgage industry. It shows visitors that their positive customer experiences are real and backed by a respected review platform.
Show Actual Customers Using Your Product
To really amp up your social proof game, let your customers do the talking (or, better yet, the showing).
It’s no secret that user-generated content (UGC) is a powerhouse. 82% of consumers say they’re more likely to buy from brands that use UGC in their marketing. That’s a huge opportunity you can’t ignore.
Why This Works
UGC provides social proof that your product delivers as promised. Seeing real customers use your product creates an instant connection, making it easier for potential buyers to picture themselves having a similar positive experience.
It’s a genuine endorsement that goes beyond what your brand says. It’s what your customers are saying, visually.
This approach humanizes your brand and builds a sense of community around your products.
How to Do It Right
- Encourage customers to share photos or videos of your product in action.
- Run contests, offer incentives, or simply make it easy for them to tag you on social media.
- Then, curate the best content and showcase it on your website and social channels.
- Add context. Sharethe customer’s story or highlight how your product solved a problem for them. This turns a simple photo into a compelling case study.
Real-World Example
EXT Cabinets, a company specializing in outdoor kitchens and cabinets, rocks this tactic.
Halfway down the homepage, the company features three images of a real outdoor kitchen they designed and installed for a customer. This is proof of their work in action.
Source: extcabinets.com
This authentic showcase builds trust and helps visitors envision EXT’s products in their own homes.
Show “Real-Time” Customer Actions
Have you ever noticed those little pop-ups telling you someone just bought something? That’s real-time social proof in action, and it’s a game-changer.
This tactic taps into our natural FOMO (fear of missing out) and creates a sense of urgency that can seriously boost conversions.
Why This Works
It’s all about creating a bustling virtual storefront. When shoppers see others actively buying, it signals that your product is in demand and worth checking out.
Plus, it adds a dash of excitement to the shopping experience.
How to Do It Right
- You’ll need a tool that can track and display real-time user actions. Many ecommerce platforms offer this feature, or you can use third-party apps.
- Keep it authentic. Only show real actions, and don’t go overboard. A few well-timed notifications are more effective than a constant barrage.
- Consider customizing the messages based on your brand voice. Instead of generic “Someone purchased X,” try something more engaging, like “Jake in New York just copped our newest backpack.”
- Remember to respect privacy. Use first names only or general locations. Also, always give users the option to opt out of being featured in these notifications.
Real-World Example
Tailored Athlete, a brand specializing in athletic fit menswear, nails this approach.
On the Athletic Fit Jeans collections page, the brand uses pop-ups to show when other shoppers add items to their cart or complete a purchase. It’s subtle but effective, creating a sense that you’re shopping alongside other fitness-minded guys.
Source: tailoredathlete.com
This is another clever way to leverage social proof and nudge hesitant shoppers toward making a purchase.
Allow Granular Product Star Ratings
A single overall star rating can’t tell the whole story. That’s where granular product ratings come in.
This tactic gives potential buyers a more detailed look at what customers think about specific aspects of your product or service.
Why This Works
It shows you’re not afraid of transparency. You commit to helping shoppers make informed decisions based on what matters most to them.
Maybe they care more about ease of use than price or durability over design. Granular ratings let them zero in on what’s important.
How to Do It Right
- Outline what it is about your product or service that customers care about. This might include quality, value for money, customer service, or specific features.
- Create separate rating categories for each.
- Make sure your review system allows customers to rate these individual aspects easily.
- Keep it simple–a 5-star scale for each category usually does the trick.
- Then, display these ratings prominently on your product pages.
- Analyze this data. It can give you valuable insights into where you’re excelling and where you might need to improve.
Real-World Example
Main Clinic Supply, a supplier of medical oxygen equipment, uses this tactic effectively.
On the Inogen One G4 Portable Oxygen Concentrator product page, the supplier allows customers to rate different aspects of their experience. Buyers can score the company, delivery, price, product, and even whether they’d purchase again.
Source: mainclinicsupply.com
This approach works brilliantly for Main Clinic Supply. By breaking down ratings this way, potential customers are given a clear picture of what to expect. This is especially powerful in their niche, where trust and reliability are vital.
Combine Customer Reviews with Multimedia Uploads
Multimedia reviews should be already a must-have rather than a nice-to-have. Testimonials in text form are great, but adding images or videos takes it to a whole new level.
In fact, testimonial videos created by actual customers get 85% more views than branded content because they feel more authentic and relatable.
Why This Works
It brings reviews to life. Seeing real people using your product or showcasing results adds a layer of credibility that words alone can’t match.
Multimedia reviews go beyond words to visually demonstrate the product’s benefits in real-world settings, which helps potential buyers connect emotionally and envision their own positive experiences.
How to Do It Right
- Make sure your review system supports image and video uploads.
- Encourage customers to share their experiences visually by offering incentives.
- Keep it simple. The easier it is to upload, the more likely people are to do it.
- Feature your multimedia reviews prominently on your product pages, social media, and even in ads. It is content gold, so make the most of it.
Real-World Example
This is a popular social proof tactic for online retailers who sell accessories. When a shopper sees how a particular item looks once an actual customer has fixed it in place, it is a powerful conversion trigger, as illustrated here by Moto Machines, a motorbike accessory store.
Allowing a customer the opportunity to talk about how their purchase not only enhanced their biking experience, but also showed other shoppers the result of their purchase is social proof gold.
Source: Screenshot by User
Demonstrate How Your Product Helped Your Customers
Over 62% of marketers say case studies are effective in generating leads. That’s because they tell a story that potential customers can relate to.
That makes showing exactly how your product solves real problems for real customers a next-level social proof tactic.
Why This Works
This approach goes beyond vague praise. It shows concrete results and paints a clear picture of how your product or service makes a difference.
Case studies make your product relatable and position it as a proven solution.
How to Do It Right
- Gather your best success stories.
- Reach out to those customers and ask if they’d be willing to share their experience.
- When creating the case study, focus on the problem they faced, how your product solved it, and the measurable results they achieved.
- Use quotes, data, and visuals to bring the story to life.
- Feature these case studies prominently, share them on social media, and use them in your sales process.
Real-World Example
Trello, a project management platform, crushes this tactic.
A case study shows how the platform helped UNICEF manage teams and organize operations. It’s packed with direct quotes praising the platform and images demonstrating how UNICEF used Trello to reach their goals.
Source: trello.com
Showcasing how they helped a well-known organization tackle complex challenges allows Trello to demonstrate their platform’s value to potential users.
Final Thoughts
These strategies are just the beginning. The digital landscape is constantly evolving, and so should your approach to building trust.
So, take the first step. Experiment, measure, and show the world how your product truly helps. Because in the end, the most powerful story you can tell is the one your customers are already living.
For more information about digital marketing, check out our blog. To book an appointment, call 866-208-3095 or contact us here.
